Fantasy Surf Sessions
❮ Back

The Fantasy Wash-Up: Men's Trestles WSL Fantasy

Event Location Photo

The Fantasy Wash-Up: Men's Trestles WSL Fantasy

Last updated September 3, 2015 by Balyn McDonald

So,  Flores eh?  I didn’t see that coming,  did I?  The beauty of the WSL Fantasy Surfing is that each new contest provides a fresh start,  a new opportunity,  hell,  a shot at redemption.  Regardless of how your team went at Tahiti,  there’s plenty to get excited about;  Trestles offers the elite tour surfers the closest possible conditions to a surfers’  playground and we’re about to see some top-shelf,  high performance surfing take place.  Let’s get picking…

I won’t go over my 3 rules of team selection in detail again,  but if you’re interested you can go back to my original article here, or visit my Fantasy Surfing 101 guide here.  All you really need to remember is that the draw,  forecast and surfer’s form should all be equally considered.

Sleeper Picks:

People like to stand out from the crowd,  especially if it means success.  Aritz and Bruno were excellent values last contest,  and Kerr surprised everyone.  I jokingly referred to the dark horse picks as Hiroto Ohhara Picks last event,  however with Hiroto being added to the draw as a wildcard,  I’m guessing that term could just be confusing.  These surfers are all owned by less than 10% of all players (at time of writing)  and could well be worth a look:

Tier A:  Josh Kerr (1%) – If form counts for anything, then Kerr deserves more than 1%.  He doesn’t have the easiest first round heat,  but could certainly surprise everyone with a decent showing.

Tier A:  Jeremy Flores (1%) – That’s right, the winner of the previous contest is being given the cold shoulder here.  You may argue that Tahiti is very different from Lowers,  but Flores took 2nd  at this very venue only 4 months ago at the QS Oakley Lowers Pro.  This guy screams sleeper.

Tier B:  Ace Buchan (6%) – Ace got 3rd  in this event last year.  Just sayin’…

Tier B:  Taj Burrow (7%) – Taj isn’t exactly in the form of his life,  but he does have the 3rd  highest heat average overall for this event and he did win here 2 years ago.  Your call.

Tier C:  Matt Banting (2%) – These waves suit Banting perfectly.  His injury is a concern though,  so I’d watch carefully in the lead up to R1. *Edit:  Banting is now OUT, replaced by Hermes.  He’s still owned by 2% of people though…

Tier C:  Brett Simpson (7%) – Not really.  I was just checking to see if you were actually paying attention.

If sleeper picks aren’t your thing and you like to run with the crowd,  Medina (73%),  JJF (47%),  Filipe Toledo (41%)  and Mick Fanning (40%)  will have you loving the safety of the crowd.

By the Numbers:

The draw for this event has switched more than Buttons Kaluhiokalani.  The list below represents the current heat draw (as of writing) with the Surf-Stats projected points added to each of the surfers:

*Edit:  Changes to the heat draw after Banting and Smith’s withdrawals are in bold

Heat 1:  Slater – 93.66,  Andre – 65.90,  Payne – 69.97

Heat 2:  Toledo – 126.93,  Buchan – 73.28,  Simpson – 64.42

Heat 3:  Wilson – 124.29,  Zietz – 107.81,  Aranburu –

Heat 4:  Wright – 90.34, Asing – 59.66,  Hermes – 

Heat 5:  Fanning – 112.13,  Melling – 69.30,  Ohhara – 31.22*

Heat 6:  De Souza – 113.31,  Bourez – 90.34,  Crane – 23.07*

Heat 7:  Flores – 106.42,  Parkinson – 106.87,  Hall – 46.45

Heat 8:  Kerr – 96.53,  Wilkinson – 57.32,  Andino – 94.20

Heat 9:  Ferreira – 91.79,  Florence – 113.37,  Christie – 64.93

Heat 10:  Medina – 107.68,  Durbidge – 101.49,  Patacchia – 69.79

Heat 11:  Young – 106.54,  Otton – 65.92,  Hobgood – 59.96

Heat 12:  Burrow – 112.77,  Dantas – 98.86,  Pupo – 83.74

*Limited data, 0.7 < AUC < 0.8


If you were to use this data in isolation, the following conclusions could be drawn:

  1. There will be some tight heats.  Kerr vs.  Andino in H8 and Flores/Parko in H7 have virtually nothing in them.  Does anyone remember De Souza vs.  Toledo last year?  That tight.  Now, raw data can’t always be counted on to predict the future,  but it sure makes for an exciting R1 if it bears any resemblance to reality.
  2. Scores should be pretty high;  the predicted surfer totals are slightly above those of Tahiti.
  3. The best possible team looks like this:


Tier A:  Toledo – 126.93,  Wilson – 124.29

Tier B:  Florence – 113.37,  Burrow – 112.77,  Zietz – 107.81  and Medina – 107.68

Tier C:  Andino – 94.20,  Bourez – 90.34


This team has a monster projected score of 877.39.  It also includes some quality options like Toledo, Florence and Wilson (who just dropped a great video showing some Lowers credentials while in Bali).  However,  it also has two clashes (Wilson vs.  Zeits & Burrow vs. Bourez), meaning that it doesn’t really stand up to the ‘no clash’ test.  The good news is that by sacrificing Zietz for Medina and Bourez for Pupo you only stand to lose 6.73 projected points.   *Edit:  Burrow and Bourez no longer clash,  making the team fairly solid according to the draw.

The WSL fantasy Surf-Stats Numbers team will be running with these 8 surfers (even with the clashes) in the Surf-Stats Clubhouse group,  so you can test your own picks against the numbers men (there’s more about how to sign up and try your hand at beating this team at the bottom of the page).

Team ‘Fantasy Wash-Up’

I may have had a mediocre event at Tahiti,  but I still managed to snag a few decent surfers and 53 spots.  My team for Lowers will be as follows:

Tier A:

Toledo – Toledo is virtually a must-have here.  A ballsy player would avoid him in the hope of predicting a sleeper,  but I’m not that player.  Lock him in.

Slater – Kolohe is at his home break and comes out with a better projection than Slater,  but since he made my blacklist with an underwhelming 17.47 at Tahiti,  Brother was never going to be an option.  Slater has a great heat total average,  a good run of form and a desire to prove himself in the high-performance stakes.

*Edit – Slater now has Jadson and Payne in his heat,  making his selection even more palatable.  Kolohe is now in H8 against Kerr and Wilco.  To be honest,  Kolohe looks like an excellent Tier C option,  but Blacklists cannot be negotiated.

Tier B:

JJF – His ankle should be OK by now and he can push the air game as well as anyone.  Add to that some frontside man-hacks and you’ve got the potential for a great result.

Medina – He has his mojo back and should finish the year strong.  Get him in Tier B while you can.

Parko – This is honestly Parko’s last chance;  if he finishes anywhere less than 5th,  he’s on the blacklist for the rest of 2015.  Parko should make the Quarters in his sleep,  but 2015 has been kryptonite for him.   *Edit: Parko has not sat well with me ever since I selected him.  I really want to make a bold selection in taking Melling at 2% in his place,  but I’m still not sure (mostly because Ross tipped him);  Italo could sneak in there if I get cold feet.

Taj – I know, where’s Jordy?  Well,  Jordy may still make my team,  but until I’m confident of his fitness I’ll be going with Taj.  If Jordy posts a current video of him lighting up some trestles walls,  then Burrow will need to watch from the bleachers.

*Edit:  Jordy sounds suspiciously like he won’t surf.  Taj is pretty much locked in now, especially if Bourez moves (see below).

Tier C:

Pupo – Miguel could well win his R1 heat and that’s almost enough in itself to get him in my squad.  There’s no standout Aritz or Santos option with the wildcards at this event,  so Pupo looks the safest for my money.

Banting – Now hear me out:  If Banting’s injury is fine,  and if Jordy is out,  then this looks to be a reasonable Tier C option.  If Jordy’s in,  then Taj would be out and Bourez could well take Banting’s place.  It’s complicated, so watch the injury hub to be sure.

*Edit:  Banting is OUT.  Jordy is also doubtful (double edit:  he’s OUT).  My prediction is that,  with Jordy out,  Melling will take his place in H5 and Bourez will move into H6,  avoiding a clash with Taj (these things happened, but it also meant that Pupo was drawn into H12).  I’m locking in the Spartan and I think that I’ll take Pupo anyway, even with the Taj clash.

The Blacklist:

There are some situations where research and statistics just can’t match the raw satisfaction that comes with an emotional,  knee-jerk reaction.  Sure,  it usually blows up in your face,  but it feels good at the time.  For that reason alone I have been running a Blacklist every season;  screw me over or abuse my trust and you’re on the list,  never to be picked again.  The current Blacklist for 2015 is as follows:

  • Wilko – Don’t get me wrong,  I actually like Wilko;  he’s funny,  he rips and he can pull out a decent result from time-to-time (usually about 1 each year).  The problem I have with Wilko is that he never blows up when I pick him.  In fact,  his very selection seems to guarantee an early exit.  Wilko is on the Blacklist for the benefit of us both;  I hope he does well,  but I’ll be leaving him off my team.
  • CJ – CJ has actually done well in the last 2 competitions,  I’ll pay that.  He sucked early on in the year,  though.  After giving him one-too-many chances (Fiji,  to be exact)  I decided to shelve him.  I’m sticking to my guns.
  • Kolohe – I know;  he looks good here at his home break and the data says he’ll take out Slater.  That’s not how the Blacklist works.  Kolohe hurt me at Tahiti (even though Aaron warned me in the comments section)  and I needed revenge.  Welcome aboard,  Brother.
  • Dusty Payne – I had Dusty at 2 of the first 4 events.  Listed.
  • Simpo – I’ve just lost faith with Brett.  He’s a great surfer,  but he is toxic for fantasy.  I’ve been steering clear of poor Simpo for 2 years now.
  • Micro – Glenn Hall worked his arse off on the QS for years,  earning his stripes and his spot on tour.  I’m not picking him though,  not even if Ross Williams decides to recommend him.

*Edit:  I’ve scratched Parko from my team;  he’s not on the blacklist yet,  but he’s trending grey and his results here will be crucial for gaining selection in Europe.

Surf-Stats Clubhouse:

Now that you know the team break-downs,  it’s time for you to create a team that will outclass them,  right?  The easiest way to prove your dominance is to sign up at the Clubhouse (password ‘fantasy’).  Inside you’ll find The Fantasy Wash-Up team,  the Surf-Stats Numbers Team and the teams of any other readers willing to throw down the fantasy gauntlet.  The winner of each contest will get a shout-out in the wrap-up article and bragging rights until the next event.  We are also looking at some possible prizes in the future,  so watch this space.

Lastly,  I have set up a page that links all of my articles and connects you to the WSL fantasy universe.  If you like what I’m doing then follow The Fantasy Wash-Up on Facebook and get some fantasy goodness in your newsfeed.

As always, feel free to comment or leave your team selections below.


See You in the Clubhouse,

The Fantasy Wash-Up

Balyn McDonald grew up on the east coast of Australia,  nourishing his passion for surfing through a diet of empty beach breaks,  Taylor Steele VHS cassettes and poor amateur competition results.  If you buy him a beer he’ll most likely bore you with anecdotes of who he thinks will win the title or list the reasons why goofy-footers have it harder on tour.  He has recently spent more time building his fantasy team than actually surfing,  a fact which is particularly sad considering he is only ranked 823rd.  His surfing/WSL tour related Facebook page,  The Fantasy Wash-Up can be found here.

Go to Top